How Can Beneficiaries Remove an Executor for Breach of Fiduciary Duty?

By Ryland & Merchak, PC
Young couples consulting with professional regarding estate planning

When someone you love passes away, you expect the executor named in the will to settle the estate honestly and on time. Many executors do. Some don't.

Missed deadlines, unexplained withdrawals, and an executor who quietly moves into the family home are all reasons beneficiaries come to us, and their question is usually the same: can we get this person replaced? In Virginia, the answer is often yes.

Working with a Northern Virginia estate probate lawyer who knows the court's standard and the tools the system already provides can make the process go much more smoothly. Contact us if you have any questions or concerns regarding the probate process.

What Counts as a Breach of Fiduciary Duty by an Executor in Virginia

An executor (Virginia law calls the role a personal representative) owes duties of loyalty, care, and transparency to the estate and its beneficiaries. Common breaches include:

  • Self-dealing, such as buying estate property at a discount, renting the decedent's home to themselves, or paying their own business from estate funds.

  • Commingling, meaning mixing estate money with personal accounts.

  • Unreasonable delay in selling assets, paying debts, or making distributions without a valid reason.

  • Failing to file required paperwork with the court's Commissioner of Accounts.

  • Favoring one beneficiary over others contrary to the will.

Keep in mind that not every frustration is a breach. Estates with real estate, business interests, or tax issues can legitimately take a year or more. Also, assets that pass outside probate, like jointly held accounts and life insurance with named beneficiaries, don't belong on the estate inventory. A missing asset isn't always evidence of wrongdoing.

Warning Signs Beneficiaries Should Watch For

Under Va. Code § 64.2-1300, a personal representative must file an inventory within four months after the order conferring their authority, and each item must be listed at market value as of the decedent's date of death. After that, the executor must file periodic accountings showing every dollar received and spent.

The warning signs we see most often are a missed inventory deadline, accountings that show large unexplained expenses, refusal to answer reasonable questions, and an executor who treats estate property as their own. If you're seeing any of these, it's time to act, because estate assets that are spent or sold are often hard to recover.

Virginia's Legal Standard for Removing an Executor

Virginia gives circuit courts broad discretion here. Under Va. Code § 64.2-1410, the court may revoke a fiduciary's powers "whenever from any cause it appears proper," and any interested party may present evidence that makes such an order proper.

Virginia courts have interpreted this standard generously. The key question is whether removing the executor is in the best interest of the estate, and "friction" between individuals can justify removal. That matters in family disputes. You don't always need to prove theft. A serious, ongoing conflict that is stalling the estate can be enough.

There is also a middle option. The same statute lets the court order a new or additional bond, and if the executor doesn't comply, the court may revoke and annul the executor's powers. When we suspect mismanagement but don't yet have full proof, asking for a larger bond can protect the estate quickly. It also tends to show whether the executor can keep serving.

How the Commissioner of Accounts Can Help Beneficiaries

Every Northern Virginia circuit court, including Fairfax, Arlington, Loudoun, Prince William, and Alexandria, has a Commissioner of Accounts. The commissioner is appointed by the circuit court to supervise fiduciaries and their timely, proper filing of inventories and accounts.

Beneficiaries often overlook this office, but it can be a powerful tool. Under Va. Code § 64.2-1209, an interested person can insist on or object to matters before the commissioner, with the same rights they would have as a party to a court suit to settle the fiduciary's accounts. In practice, that means you can challenge improper expenses, excessive commissions, and missing assets in a hearing before the commissioner. The commissioner then files a report with the court, which is confirmed by law fifteen days after filing unless someone objects.

A commissioner's report documenting improper conduct can become strong evidence in a removal petition. When an executor simply stops filing, the commissioner can summon them and report the delinquency to the court.

Steps to Remove an Executor in Northern Virginia

  1. Gather the paper trail. Get copies of the will, the qualification order, the inventory, and any accountings from the Commissioner of Accounts.

  2. Put your concerns in writing. A specific written request for information gives the executor a chance to respond and creates a record if they don't.

  3. Raise objections with the commissioner. Challenging specific items in an accounting often brings problems into the open.

  4. File a petition in circuit court. The petition asks the court to revoke the executor's authority, explains why removal serves the estate, and requests a successor. The executor must receive reasonable notice before the court enters an order.

  5. Request interim protection if needed. If assets are at risk, ask the court for an additional bond or other orders to protect the estate while the case is pending.

What Happens After an Executor Is Removed

Removal doesn't end the estate. Under Va. Code § 64.2-513, upon the removal of the sole executor, administration of the estate not already administered may be granted, with the will annexed, to any person the court deems appropriate. Beneficiaries can propose a neutral successor, such as a professional fiduciary, to avoid the next round of family conflict.

Removal also doesn't erase what the former executor did. They can be held personally responsible for losses, required to repay misused funds, and denied their commission. If they were bonded, the surety bond may give the estate another source of recovery.

Protecting Your Inheritance When an Executor Fails

You don't have to watch an estate lose value while an executor ignores deadlines or puts their own interests first. Virginia law gives beneficiaries real options, from objections before the Commissioner of Accounts to a petition for removal. At Ryland & Merchak, PC, we help beneficiaries review accountings, challenge improper conduct, and seek removal when an executor won't do the job properly.

If you're concerned about how an estate is being handled, contact our office today to schedule a consultation. We'll review the estate filings, explain your options, and help you decide on the next step.